1604: Imaginary Dad by Tina Cane

20261117 Slowdown Tina Cane

1604: Imaginary Dad by Tina Cane

TRANSCRIPT

I’m Maggie Smith, and this is The Slowdown.

The first movie I ever saw in the theatre was Annie, which I saw with my mother in 1982 at a theatre that no longer exists. I was five years old, and I was obsessed with Annie — the music, the costumes, even the setting: New York City during the Great Depression. I had the record, too, and I listened to those actors belt out those hit songs over and over, singing every word, until the record was too scratched to play. “Hard Knock Life.” “Tomorrow.” “Little Girls.”

But “Maybe” was the one that always got to me. In that melancholy, wistful song, little red-haired Annie is in the orphanage, imagining the parents she doesn’t remember and desperately hoping they’ll come back to get her someday. She wonders what they look like, and what they enjoy doing, and what their lives are like without her.

If you’re familiar with the song, you might be humming or singing it on your own already: “Betcha he reads / Betcha she sews / Maybe she's made me / a closet of clothes / Maybe they're strict / As straight as a line / Don't really care / as long as they're mine.”

It’s so poignant because it’s so relatable. So human. I listened to her sing that song from my house with my family, but the longing still made sense to me. I could imagine missing someone dear to me, or never having the chance to know them. That’s what poems and songs and stories can do for us: help us inhabit and understand another person’s perspective.

When someone is missing from your life — a father, a mother, a sibling, a partner, a child — we instinctively use our imaginations to fill in the blanks. We imagine what they might look like, or sound like, or act like. How they spend their days without us. How they might treat us if they were around. How life might be different with that role filled.

A significant absence is a kind of a presence in itself: the void is always there, taking up space. Today’s poem explores such an absence — and such a presence.


Imaginary Dad
by Tina Cane

                                                Was so imaginary       he ceased to exist

he wasn’t sleeping       in a treehouse       or stalking the woods

in fatigues       cheeks smeared green       with camouflage grease

a knife between his teeth         like I had envisioned him

he was just a married guy
                                                                   living

in a small town       near a dozen       of my made-up cousins

kin so distant       they didn’t even know       to miss me

all their lives
                                      I’d picture them

fumbling in their pockets       through loose change

patting their pants      in search of something

left behind       all the time       never knowing

what it was
                                or what it was like

to eat Twizzlers       while watching       Apocalypse Now

in a darkened theater     on Bleecker St.
                                                                                               to think

each time a soldier       appeared on screen       Now, there’s a dad

if I ever saw one      because of course      they’d seen one

he was nothing like that       and he belonged to me

"Imaginary Dad" by Tina Cane. Published in Poetry (February 2023). Used by permission of the poet.