1607: Stop the Cocoon by Elizabeth Metzger

1607: Stop the Cocoon by Elizabeth Metzger
TRANSCRIPT
I’m Maggie Smith, and this is The Slowdown.
One of the earliest things I remember making at school was a project on metamorphosis. I think I was in kindergarten. There was a cotton ball for an egg, a blob of paint meant to be the chrysalis, or cocoon, and finally, a large painted butterfly.
Years ago, I read a book about metamorphosis with my kids. I knew the basic steps of the transformation, dating back to my kindergarten project — egg, larva, chrysalis, butterfly — but I had no idea what happened inside a chrysalis. I didn’t know what allowed a caterpillar to exit a butterfly after what I’d assumed was a strange, shape-shifting nap. What I learned thrilled me: a caterpillar liquefies, then reconstitutes itself, becoming a different creature entirely.
The most fascinating part? The butterfly may actually carry within it knowledge — memories — from its first iteration. It is the same, and yet it is completely different. It is itself and not. It carries inside it the old life while living the new one, which allows it to fly.
If there is a more popular metaphor for transformation, I don’t know it! But more and more, I wonder if our cultural focus on growth and change might not always be healthy. What if, metaphorically speaking, some caterpillars don’t long to be butterflies? What if, metaphorically speaking of course, some caterpillars are fine staying caterpillars?
It’s impossible to turn on TV or scroll reels on Instagram without being bombarded with opportunities for self-improvement. We’re constantly being sold products and services to help us better ourselves. Nothing’s wrong with wanting to do and be better — I’d argue that’s part of what it is to be human — but also, what’s wrong with being satisfied with who you are, how you look, and what you have?
Today’s poem meditates on just that: the idea that we’re all on our own trajectories.
Stop the Cocoon
by Elizabeth Metzger
If you choose to remain a caterpillar I would not mind the lack of reciprocity. My passion would be enough for both of us. You would be permitted to forget me but I would play near you, if not with you, keep you from dying of hopelessness bring you the leaves you like best watch for your preference crunchy and dead with a spot of green build you micro-mansions surprise tunnels that transform nothing only thicken the line of your being alone in my affection. I would never be embarrassed to suck your many legs I tally each night. You may not remember me the next gloaming but you would lose all instincts to hide before flight. I would make and remake you a world just for you to move in where you would not stuff and bide your time just to leave me. I would be all the food you need, your ready hungry guard mouth always open. Could you choose that for me in spite of my larger life let me drink glistening dabs off your body and call it joy in the meantime instead of progress?
“Stop the Cocoon” by Elizabeth Metzger from THE GOING IS FOREVER © 2026 Elizabeth Metzger. Used with the permission of The Permissions Company, LLC on behalf of Milkweed Editions.


